Haunted Hays Cemetery

East of Indianapolis in central Indiana is the small town of Wilkinson. In early days you could leave the town on Main Street and follow it to a cemetery that is basically out in the middle of nowhere. The Main Street Cemetery, also known as the Hays Cemetery, has over the years developed the reputation of being haunted. It is at the end of a rather rough gravel road and the road climbs a small rise and cuts across the center of the cemetery. Put Hays Cemetery in Google maps and you’ll get directions to the beginning of the gravel road.

The video shows that the Hays Cemetery is a neatly kept and open cemetery. There is plenty of room between the headstones. Several of the headstones list the names of Hays family members. Unfortunately lots of the stones have suffered from decades of weathering, making them very hard to read.

One of the Hays family who died in 1872

Sad marker for a sweet young girl









Now to the haunting stuff. Several sources on the internet refer to the “fact” that this is a very haunted cemetery. One of the paranormal things has been the discussion of a ‘devil child’. There is supposed to be a pitch-fork shaped tree growing from the child’s grave. There are reports that local kids used to go out at night and try to call ghosts. We also saw one reference to some man hanging his wife from a tree and shooting her as well, thus spawning another ghostly presence.

Based on location, this might be the “Devil Child”

Ghostly wise, we didn’t see anything. We didn’t hear anything. We didn’t sense anything. We thought that this was a beautiful, peaceful and quiet resting place for many centuries gone Indiana early pioneers.

18 thoughts on “Haunted Hays Cemetery

  1. Pingback: Haunted Baby Doll Bridge or Hays Bridge | Roadtirement

  2. Pingback: Haunted Baby Doll Bridge or Hays Bridge – Roadtirement | Ups Downs Family History

  3. Pingback: Haunted Hays Cemetery — Roadtirement – Arlington Pl Hendersonville NC~Rats, Swindlers & Cheats~All 2120 For KalyArlingtonPlaca

  4. I used to go there in the 70’s and 80’s. Heard lots of stories. The cemetery was trashed, knives everywhere, garbage, etc… There were a whole lot more tomb stones. Most of the stories are made up and the bad juju there is from idiots dabbling in things they have no understanding of.


    • Your assessment of the validity (or lack thereof) of the stories is spot on. as is your condemnation of those messing in areas in which they have no clue. As we noted, we felt nor saw anything otherworldly. Interesting that you saw more stones decades ago… Thanks for sharing.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s